(Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
-
- PlutoniumLounger
- Posts: 16789
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 23:23
- Location: brings.slot.perky
(Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
Here i am, yet again encrypting a data partition, and the perennial question pops up.
The largest (visible) file on my old laptop's C-Drive is in "C:\Windows\winsxs\ManifestCache\" and is about 111_MB
The largest (visible) file on my old laptop's data partition, apart from a Windows.ISO which I downloaded this morning at 4+GB, is in "T:\Appl\MicrosoftUpdates\Office2013\" and is about 806_MB.
I think of a DVD image as 4.7GB or thereabouts, and while I play with aggregates of movies on DVDs, I don't store the aggregates on my data partition.
So I chose "No, never more than 4GB" and got on with life.
Have I now prevented myself from ever having a 5GB file stored?
Or will Windows get usefully smart for once and split a 5GB file into a somewhat inefficient two portions?
I suspect that the 4GB boundary is something to do with how Windows file system maps chunks of files to the hard drive, and that larger files have to be allocated in larger chunks.
If this supposition is true, then choosing "yes, larger than 4GB" suggests that all the other files, including the 1KB notepad files that contain 32 bytes, will each occupy significantly more space, just for the sake of the odd large file.
Right now, if someone offered me a 5GB file containing The Meaning Of Life, I'd buy another 64GB memory key and use it as storage, and not worry about the large file being on my day-to-day use encrypted data partition.
Thanks for any confirmation or correction.
Chris
The largest (visible) file on my old laptop's C-Drive is in "C:\Windows\winsxs\ManifestCache\" and is about 111_MB
The largest (visible) file on my old laptop's data partition, apart from a Windows.ISO which I downloaded this morning at 4+GB, is in "T:\Appl\MicrosoftUpdates\Office2013\" and is about 806_MB.
I think of a DVD image as 4.7GB or thereabouts, and while I play with aggregates of movies on DVDs, I don't store the aggregates on my data partition.
So I chose "No, never more than 4GB" and got on with life.
Have I now prevented myself from ever having a 5GB file stored?
Or will Windows get usefully smart for once and split a 5GB file into a somewhat inefficient two portions?
I suspect that the 4GB boundary is something to do with how Windows file system maps chunks of files to the hard drive, and that larger files have to be allocated in larger chunks.
If this supposition is true, then choosing "yes, larger than 4GB" suggests that all the other files, including the 1KB notepad files that contain 32 bytes, will each occupy significantly more space, just for the sake of the odd large file.
Right now, if someone offered me a 5GB file containing The Meaning Of Life, I'd buy another 64GB memory key and use it as storage, and not worry about the large file being on my day-to-day use encrypted data partition.
Thanks for any confirmation or correction.
Chris
Fill your face with laughter, then there will be no room for tears.
-
- PlatinumLounger
- Posts: 5564
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 08:33
- Location: A cathedral city in England
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
Are you just revisiting the fact that the FAT32 file system can hold files no larger than 4 GB? If you want to save files greater than 4 GB you need to use the NTFS or exFAT file format (no, I've never used that either) on your disk partition.
This is all 1993 stuff, though...
This is all 1993 stuff, though...

John Gray
The family is nature's way of passing inequality down through the generations.
The family is nature's way of passing inequality down through the generations.
-
- Administrator
- Posts: 12938
- Joined: 16 Jan 2010, 15:49
- Location: London, Europe
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
Why not just format the encrypted partition with NTFS and forget about all this
StuartR
-
- PlutoniumLounger
- Posts: 16789
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 23:23
- Location: brings.slot.perky
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
Hi John. I think that you are saying "Yes" and "No" respectively in answer to the two questions.John Gray wrote: ↑27 Jul 2020, 19:37Are you just revisiting the fact that the FAT32 file system can hold files no larger than 4 GB? If you want to save files greater than 4 GB you need to use the NTFS or exFAT file format (no, I've never used that either) on your disk partition.
This is all 1993 stuff, though...![]()
Yes, it may well be 1993 stuff, but I had no files that size back then, and it is only in the past half-dozen years that I have pondered DVDs with 4.7GB capacity. I am prompted into this by having to use UEFI which leads into GPT which is for "hard drives greater than 2TB", which is not my concern.
Cheers
Chris
Fill your face with laughter, then there will be no room for tears.
-
- PlutoniumLounger
- Posts: 16789
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 23:23
- Location: brings.slot.perky
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
Hi Stuart.
In answer to your question, I suppose that it is because the Vercrypt/Truecrypt question isn't proposed as NTFS-or-not, but seems more like a question about my personal data habits.
I already use NTFS, otherwise I would not have been able to d/l a Windows ISO file yesterday, right? Or to make use of Burn-ing software.
I consider the Veracrypt/Truecrypt question to be misleading. It does not explicitly state that I will not be able to store a file greater than 4GB; that is what led me to wonder if there was a way, albeit inefficient, for Vera/Truecrypt to split a >4GB file into smaller chunks.
Cheers
Chris
Fill your face with laughter, then there will be no room for tears.
-
- Administrator
- Posts: 12938
- Joined: 16 Jan 2010, 15:49
- Location: London, Europe
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
Any file system will split files into smaller chunks to fit into the available free space.
The 4GB limit is not to do with the number of chunks. It is due to the limited size of a data structure that maps each block of the file to a physical location.
The 4GB limit is not to do with the number of chunks. It is due to the limited size of a data structure that maps each block of the file to a physical location.
StuartR
-
- PlutoniumLounger
- Posts: 16789
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 23:23
- Location: brings.slot.perky
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
Hi Stuart.
I guess this is what EaseUs did when it made a system image backup for me:-
So I believe that if I specify "No, never more than 4GB" I will be using smaller physical writes, so that storage is a little more efficient, excepting when I go over the 4GB file size, and even then the introduced inefficiency is related to dealing with several file-portions.The 4GB limit is not to do with the number of chunks. It is due to the limited size of a data structure that maps each block of the file to a physical location.
In the screen snapshot above will have to issue five calls to write to a DVD, one for each version.
Cheers
Chris
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Fill your face with laughter, then there will be no room for tears.
-
- Administrator
- Posts: 12938
- Joined: 16 Jan 2010, 15:49
- Location: London, Europe
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
No Chris. You CAN'T create a file bigger than 4GB on file systems like FAT. What EaseUs did was create 5 different files, none of which is bigger than 4GB.
StuartR
-
- PlutoniumLounger
- Posts: 16789
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 23:23
- Location: brings.slot.perky
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
Yes Yes Stuart.
I figured that that was the work of EaseUs, not Windows, but I classed it under the general heading of "Any file system will split files ..."; including EaseUs and not restricted to Windows. I note with interest that the largest file on my encrypted T: data drive is the paging file.
My original question about 4GB files was related to an encrypted backup data drive.
Cheers
Chris
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Fill your face with laughter, then there will be no room for tears.
-
- Administrator
- Posts: 12938
- Joined: 16 Jan 2010, 15:49
- Location: London, Europe
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
EaseUs is not a file system, it is a program. A file system is something like NTFS or FAT which actually organizes the bits and bytes of physical disk space.
StuartR
-
- PlatinumLounger
- Posts: 5564
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 08:33
- Location: A cathedral city in England
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
I'm beginning to think that this would solve All Known Problems™...

John Gray
The family is nature's way of passing inequality down through the generations.
The family is nature's way of passing inequality down through the generations.
-
- 5StarLounger
- Posts: 1165
- Joined: 21 Jan 2011, 16:51
- Location: Florida
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
IIRC, another benefit to NTFS is files smaller than a certain size (4K?) are actually stored in the "directory" which I believe is the Master File Table, and don't actually get allocated their own separate cluster.
PJ in (usually sunny) FL
-
- PlutoniumLounger
- Posts: 16789
- Joined: 24 Jan 2010, 23:23
- Location: brings.slot.perky
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
@Stuart and @John.
You both are "spot on".
This morning I tracked my inability to d/l an IMG file to my old Win7 DELL laptop data partition being encrypted without large file support (greater than 4 GB).
My clues
(1) On the Veracrypted old Win7 DELL six failed attempts to d/l an IMG file for Office 21 from a retail site
(2) On the Veracrypted new Win11 ACER immediate success in downloading that IMG file
(3) Success in making a copy of the IMG file from the Acer to my Veracrypted USB hard disk drive.
(4) Failure to copy the IMG file from the USB drive to the Win7 DELL I suspect that this can be traced back to a decision I made four years ago .
Lesson Learned (my Thick Skull). I should examine my laptop partitions and my external media partitions and methodically convert them to NTFS.
I may have to re-crypt some encrypted partitions.
Thanks, Chris
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Fill your face with laughter, then there will be no room for tears.
-
- PlatinumLounger
- Posts: 4113
- Joined: 24 Oct 2010, 23:39
- Location: Canton, Ohio USA
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
Nothing to add but wanted to subscribe to this thread. Posting is the only way I found to do that. I think that will work.
Regards,
hlewton
hlewton
-
- Administrator
- Posts: 80042
- Joined: 16 Jan 2010, 00:14
- Status: Microsoft MVP
- Location: Wageningen, The Netherlands
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
You don't need to reply to a thread to subscribe to it.
Click the 'Topic Tools' drop-down (the wrench icon) above the first post in the thread and select 'Subscribe topic'.
Click the 'Topic Tools' drop-down (the wrench icon) above the first post in the thread and select 'Subscribe topic'.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.
Best wishes,
Hans
Hans
-
- PlatinumLounger
- Posts: 4113
- Joined: 24 Oct 2010, 23:39
- Location: Canton, Ohio USA
Re: (Vera/Truecrypt) Store files larger than 4GB?
Thank you. I knew there was a way but I couldn't find it. I will try to remember this.
Regards,
hlewton
hlewton